Repository Universitas Pakuan

Detail Karya Ilmiah Dosen

Erik Meijaard, Douglas Sheil, Julie Sherman, Liana Chua, Safwanah Ni'matullah, Kerrie Wilson, Marc Ancrenaz, Darmawan Liswanto, Serge A, Wich, Benoit Goossens, Hjalmar S. Kühl, Maria Voigt, Yaya Rayadin, Yuyun Kurniawan , Agus Trianto , Dolly Priatna, Graham L. Banes, Emily Massingham, John Payne And Andrew J. Marshall

Judul : Restoring the orangutan in a Whole- or Half-Earth context
Abstrak :

Various global-scale proposals exist to reduce the loss of biological diversity. These include the Half-Earth and Whole-Earth visions that respectively seek to set aside half the planet for wildlife conservation or to diversify conservation practices fundamentally and change the economic systems that determine environmental harm. Here we assess these visions in the specific context of Bornean orangutans Pongo pygmaeus and their conservation. Using an expert-led process we explored three scenarios over a 10-year time frame: continuation of Current Conditions, a Half-Earth approach and a Whole-Earth approach. In addition, we examined a 100-year population recovery scenario assuming 0% offtake of Bornean orangutans. Current Conditions were predicted to result in a population c. 73% of its current size by 2032. Half-Earth was judged comparatively easy to achieve and predicted to result in an orangutan population of c. 87% of its current size by 2032. Whole-Earth was anticipated to lead to greater forest loss and ape killing, resulting in a prediction of c. 44% of the current orangutan population for 2032. Finally, under the recovery scenario, populations could be c. 148% of their current size by 2122. Although we acknowledge uncertainties in all of these predictions, we conclude that the Half-Earth and Whole-Earth visions operate along different timelines, with the implementation of Whole-Earth requiring too much time to benefit orangutans. None of the theorized proposals provided a complete solution, so drawing elements from each will be required. We provide recommendations for equitable outcomes.

Tahun : 2022 Media Publikasi : Jurnal Internasional
Kategori : Jurnal No/Vol/Tahun : 2 / 12 / 2022
ISSN/ISBN : https://doi.org/10.1017/S003060532200093X
PTN/S : Universitas Pakuan Program Studi : PENDIDIKAN KEPENDUDUKAN DAN LINGKUNGAN HIDUP
Bibliography :

A B R A M , N.K., M E I J A A R D , E., W E L L S , J.A., A N C R E N A Z , M., P E L L I E R ,
A.-S., R U N T I N G , R.K. et al. () Mapping perceptions of species
threats and population trends to inform conservation efforts:
the Bornean orangutan case study. Diversity and Distributions,
, .
A K Ç A K AY A , H.R., B E N N E T T , E.L., B R O O K S , T.M., G R AC E , M.K.,
H E A T H , A., H E D G E S , S. et al. () Quantifying species recovery
and conservation success to develop an IUCN Green List of Species.
Conservation Biology, , .
A N C R E N A Z , M., D A B E K , L. & ON E I L , S. () The costs of exclusion:
recognizing a role for local communities in biodiversity
conservation. PLOS Biology, , .
A N C R E N A Z , M., O R A M , F., N A R D I Y O N O , N, S I L M I , M., J O P O N Y ,
M.E.M., V O I G T , M. et al. () Importance of orangutans in small
fragments for maintaining metapopulation dynamics. Frontiers
in Forests and Global Change, , .
A R D I A N S Y A H , F. & J O T Z O , F. () Decentralization and avoiding
deforestation. The case of Indonesia. In Federal Reform Strategies:
Lessons From Asia and Australia (eds S. Howes & M.G. Rao),
pp. . Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.
A R N O L D , L.L. () Deforestation in decentralised Indonesia: whats
law got to do with it? Law, Environment and Development Journal,
, [xiii].
B U D I H A R TA , S., M E I J A A R D , E., E R S K I N E , P.D., R O N D I N I N I , C.,
P A C I F I C I , M. & W I L S O N , K.A. () Restoring degraded tropical
forests for carbon and biodiversity. Environmental Research Letters,
, .
B Ü S C H E R , B. & F L E T C H E R , R. () Towards convivial conservation.
Conservation & Society, , .
B Ü S C H E R , B., F L E T C H E R , R., B R O C K I N G T O N , D., S A N D B R O O K , C.,
A D A M S , W.M., C A M P B E L L , L. et al. () Half-Earth or Whole
Earth? Radical ideas for conservation, and their implications.
Oryx, , .
B U T T , S. () Traditional land rights before the Indonesian
constitutional court. Law, Environment and Development Journal,
, .
C A F A R O , P., B U T L E R , T., C R I S T , E., C R Y E R , P., D I N E R S T E I N , E.,
K O P N I N A , H. et al. () If we want a whole Earth, nature needs
half: a response to Büscher et al. Oryx, , .
C A R D I N A L E , B.J., D U F F Y , J.E., G O N Z A L E Z , A., H O O P E R , D.U.,
P E R R I N G S , C., V E N A I L , P. et al. () Biodiversity loss and its
impact on humanity. Nature, , .
C A S S O N , A. & O B I D Z I N S K I , K. () From new order to regional
autonomy: shifting dynamics of illegal logging in Kalimantan,
Indonesia. World Development, , .
C H U A , L., F A I R , H., S C H R E E R , V., S T Ę P I E Ń , A. & T H U N G , P.H.
() Only the orangutans get a life jacket. American Ethnologist,
, .
C H U A , L., H A R R I S O N , M., C H E Y N E , S., F A I R , H., M I L N E , S., P A L M E R ,
A. et al. () Conservation and the social sciences: beyond
critique and co-optation. A case study from orangutan
conservation. People and Nature, , .
C R I S T , E., K O P N I N A , H., C A F A R O , P., G R AY , J., R I P P L E , W.J.,
S A F I N A , C. et al. () Protecting half the planet and transforming
human systems are complementary goals. Frontiers in Conservation
Science, , .
D AV I S , J.T., M E N G E R S E N , K., A B R A M , N., A N C R E N A Z , M., W E L L S , J. &
M E I J A A R D , E. () Its not just conflict that motivates killing of
orangutans. PLOS ONE, , e.
D Í A Z , S., S E T T E L E , J., B R O N D Í Z I O , E.S., N G O , H.T., A G A R D , J.,
A R N E T H , A. et al. () Pervasive human-driven decline of life
on Earth points to the need for transformative change.
Science, , eaax.
E L L I S , E.C. & M E H R A B I , Z. () Half Earth: promises, pitfalls, and
prospects of dedicating half of Earths land to conservation.
Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, , .
FAO () Global Forest Resources Assessment . Food and
Agriculture Organization, Rome, Italy.
F R E U N D , C., R A H M A N , E. & K N O T T , C. () Ten years of orangutan-
related wildlife crime investigation in West Kalimantan, Indonesia.
American Journal of Primatology, , .
G A M E , E., M E I J A A R D , E., S H E I L , D. & M C D O N A L D -M A D D E N , E.
() Conservation in a wicked complex world; challenges and
solutions. Conservation Letters, , .
G AV E A U , D.L.A., L O C AT E L L I , B., D E S C A L S , A., M A N U R U N G , T.,
S A L I M , M.A., H U S N A Y E N , M. et al. () Slowing oil palm
expansion and deforestation in Indonesia coincide with low oil
prices. PLOS ONE, , e.
G AV E A U , D.L.A., L O C AT E L L I , B., S A L I M , M.A., Y A E N , H., P AC H E C O , P.
& S H E I L , D. () Rise and fall of forest loss and industrial
plantations in Borneo (). Conservation Letters,
, e.
G R A C E , M., A K Ç A K AY A , H.R., B E N N E T T , E., H I LT O N -T AY LO R , C.,
L O N G , B., M I L N E R -G U L L A N D , E.J. et al. () Using historical and
palaeoecological data to inform ambitious species recovery targets.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences,
, .
H O W S O N , P. () Slippery violence in the REDD+ forests of Central
Kalimantan, Indonesia. Conservation and Society, , .
I M M OV I L L I , M. & K O K , M.T.J. () Narratives for the Half Earth
and Sharing the Planet Scenarios; A Literature Review.
PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency,
The Hague, The Netherlands.
I N T A R I N I , D.Y., Resosudarmo, I.A.P., K O M A L A S A R I , M., E K A P U T R I ,
A.D. & A G U S TAV I A , M. () Ketapang community carbon pools,
West Kalimantan, Indonesia. In REDD+ on the Ground: A Case
Book of Subnational Initiatives Across the Globe (eds E.O. Sills,
S. Atmadja, C. Sassi, A.E. de Duchelle, D. Kweka, I.A.P.
Resosudarmo & W.D. Sunderlin), pp. . Center for
International Forestry Research, Bogor, Indonesia.
J O H A N S S O N , J., S A N D S T R Ö M , C. & L U N D M A R K , T. () Inspired by
structured decision making: a collaborative approach to the
governance of multiple forest values. Ecology and Society, , .
K A R E I VA , P. () New conservation: setting the record straight and
finding common ground. Conservation Biology, , .
L E D G A R D , J. & M E I J A A R D , E. () Endangered Wildlife Should Pay
for Its Own Protection. Project Syndicate. project-syndicate.org/
commentary/digital-wallets-for-endangered-wild-animals-by-
jonathan-ledgard--and-erik-meijaard-- [accessed
 August ].
L Y N C H , O.J. & H A R W E L L , E. () Whose Natural Resources? Whose
Common Good? Towards a Paradigm of Environmental Justice and
the National Interest in Indonesia. Center for International
Environmental Law, Washington, DC, USA.
M A L AY M A I L () Sabah to develop , hectares of forest
plantations for timber by , says CM. Malay Mail,  March
10 E. Meijaard et al.
Oryx, Page 10 of 12 © The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Fauna & Flora International doi:10.1017/S003060532200093X
https://doi.org/10.1017/S003060532200093X Published online by Cambridge University Press. malaymail.com/news/malaysia////sabah-to-develop-
-hectares-of-forest-plantations-for-timber-by--s/
 [accessed  August ].
M A R S H A L L , A.J. () restoring_red_apes. Data and code for
Meijaard et al. Expert guided analysis for restoring the red ape in a
whole or half earth context. github.com/andrewjohnmarshall/
restoring_red_apes [accessed  August ].
M A R S H A L L , A.J., L AC Y , R., A N C R E N A Z , M., B Y E R S , O., H U S S O N , S.,
L E I G H T O N , M. et al. () Orangutan population biology, life
history, and conservation. Perspectives from population viability
analysis models. In Orangutans: Geographic Variation in
Behavioral Ecology and Conservation (eds S. Wich, S.U. Atmoko,
T. Mitra Setia & C.P. van Schaik), pp. . Oxford University
Press, Oxford, UK.
M A R S H A L L , A.J., N A R D I Y O N O , N., E N G S T R O M , L.M., P A M U N G K A S , B.,
P A L A P A , J., M E I J A A R D , E. et al. () The blowgun is mightier than
the chainsaw in determining population density of Bornean
orangutans (Pongo pygmaeus morio) in the forests of East
Kalimantan. Biological Conservation, , .
M E I J A A R D , E. & S H E I L , D. (a) Cuddly animals dont persuade
poor people to back conservation. Nature, , .
M E I J A A R D , E. & S H E I L , D. (b) The persistence and conservation
of Borneos mammals in lowland rain forests managed for timber:
observations, overviews and opportunities. Ecological Research,
, .
M E I J A A R D , E. & S H E I L , D. () A modest proposal for wealthy
countries to reforest their land for the common good.
Biotropica, , .
M E I J A A R D , E., B U C H O R I , D., H A D I P R A KO S O , Y., U T A M I -A T M O KO ,
S.S., T J I U , A., P R A S E T Y O , D. et al. () Quantifying killing of
orangutans and human-orangutan conflict in Kalimantan,
Indonesia. PLOS ONE, , e.
M E I J A A R D , E., N I M AT U L L A H , S., D E N N I S , R., S H E R M A N , J., O N R I Z A L
& W I C H , S.A. () The historical range and drivers of decline
of the Tapanuli orangutan. PLOS ONE, , e.
M E I J A A R D , E., S A N T I K A , T., W I L S O N , K.A., B U D I H A R T A , S.,
K U S W O R O , A., L AW , E.A. et al. () Toward improved impact
evaluation of community forest management in Indonesia.
Conservation Science and Practice, , e.
M E I J A A R D , E., S H E I L , D., N A S I , R., A U G E R I , D., R O S E N B A U M , B.,
I S K A N D A R , D. et al. () Life after Logging: Reconciling
Wildlife Conservation and Production Forestry in
Indonesian Borneo. CIFOR, WCS and UNESCO, Bogor,
Indonesia.
M E I J A A R D , E., W E L S H , A., A N C R E N A Z , M., W I C H , S., N I J M A N , V. &
M A R S H A L L , A.J. () Declining orangutan encounter rates from
Wallace to the present suggest the species was once more abundant.
PLOS ONE, , e.
M E I J A A R D , E., W I C H , S., A N C R E N A Z , M. & M A R S H A L L , A.J. ()
Not by science alone: why orangutan conservationists must think
outside the box. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences,
, .
P E L U S O , N.L. & V A N D E R G E E S T , P. () Genealogies of the political
forest and customary rights in Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand.
Journal of Asian Studies, , .
R C O R E D E V E LO P M E N T T E A M () R: A Language and Environment
for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing,
Vienna, Austria.
R AV E N E L , R.M. () Community-based logging and de facto
decentralization. Journal of Sustainable Forestry, , .
R U N T I N G , R.K., R U S L A N D I , G R I S C O M , B.W., S T R U E B I G , M.J., S AT A R ,
M., M E I J A A R D , E. et al. () Larger gains from improved
management over sparingsharing for tropical forests.
Nature Sustainability, , .
S A B A H F O R E S T R Y D E P A R T M E N T () Annual Report .
Sabah Forestry Department, Sandakan, Sabah.
S A H I D E , M.A.K., F I S H E R , M., N A S R I , N., D H A R M I A S I H , W.,
V E R H E I J E N , B. & M A R Y U D I , A. () Anticipating a new
conservation bureaucracy? Land and power in Indonesias essential
ecosystem area policy. Land Use Policy, , .
S A N T I K A , T., A N C R E N A Z , M., W I L S O N , K.A., S P E H A R , S., A B R A M , N.,
B A N E S , G.L. et al. (a) First integrative trend analysis for a great
ape species in Borneo. Scientific Reports, , .
S A N T I K A , T., B U D I H A R T A , S., L AW , E.A., S T R U E B I G , M., A N C R E N A Z ,
M., P O H , T.M. et al. (a) Does oil palm agriculture help
alleviate poverty? A multidimensional counterfactual assessment
of oil palm development in Indonesia. World Development,
, .
S A N T I K A , T., K U S WO R O , A., H U TA B A R AT , J.A., S U L H A N I , T R I S O N , S.,
R A H A R J O , S. et al. (b) Community forest management in
Indonesia: avoided deforestation in the context of anthropogenic
and climate complexities. Global Environmental Change, , .
S A N T I K A , T., M E I J A A R D , E. & W I L S O N , K.A. () Designing
multifunctional landscapes for forest conservation. Environmental
Research Letters, , .
S A N T I K A , T., S H E R M A N , J., V O I G T , M., A N C R E N A Z , M., W I C H , S.A.,
W I L S O N , K.A. et al. () Effectiveness of  years of conservation
investments in protecting orangutans. Current Biology,
, .
S A N T I K A , T., W I L S O N , K.A., B U D I H A R T A , S., K U S W O R O , A.,
M E I J A A R D , E., L AW , E.A. et al. (b) Heterogeneous impacts of
community forestry on forest conservation and poverty alleviation:
evidence from Indonesia. People and Nature, , .
S AY E R , J., B U L L , G. & E L L I O T T , C. () Mediating forest transitions:
grand design or muddling through. Conservation and Society,
, .
S C OT T , J.C. () Seeing Like a State. Yale University Press,
New Haven, USA.
S H E I L , D. & B O I S S I È R E , M. () Local people may be the best allies
in conservation. Nature, , .
S H E I L , D. & L AW R E N C E , A. () Tropical biologists, local people
and conservation: new opportunities for collaboration.
Trends in Ecology and Evolution, , .
S H E I L , D., B O I S S I È R E , M. & B E A U D O I N , G. () Unseen sentinels.
Local monitoring and control in conservations blind spots.
Ecology and Society, , .
S H E R M A N , J., A N C R E N A Z , M. & M E I J A A R D , E. () Shifting apes:
conservation and welfare outcomes of Bornean orangutan rescue
and release in Kalimantan, Indonesia. Journal for Nature
Conservation, , .
S O U L É , M. () The new conservation. Conservation Biology,
, .
S P E H A R , S.N., S H E I L , D., H A R R I S O N , T., L O U Y S , J., A N C R E N A Z , M.,
M A R S H A L L , A.J. et al. () Orangutans venture out of the
rainforest and into the Anthropocene. Science Advances,
, e.

URL : https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/oryx/article/restoring-the-orangutan-in-a-whole-or-halfearth

 

Document

 
back